Fletcher refused; Captain Roberts' answer was to send boats to take the slave cargo to safety prior to burning the vessel. It was a disaster while one party set the ship alight the other tried to unshackle the slaves. Unfortunately, the latter had a little more difficulty and soon found themselves on a burning ship still struggling to free its poor occupants. The ship went up like a tinder box, the pirates fled in their long-boats but those slaves they'd managed to free could only escape the flames by jumping into the sea.
Others below deck burned with the ship. To make matters worse these waters are shark infested; pirates and civilians alike witnessed a feeding frenzy as the sharks tore into the fleeing slaves. What the Navy had to say... Naval accounts omit Roberts attempt to free the slaves before firing the ship, typically he was not given any benefit of the doubt but there are other witnesses. In addition to this, pirates had no truck with slavery as it went against their basic principals.
They even had liberated slaves amongst their number equal to anyone aboard. In this respect we have to ask ourselves who were the real outlaws since every crown in Europe set their navy to protect the slave trade. Before leaving Porto-Nova Roberts gained some news hinting his position was known to the British men-o-war.
After informing the crew of this they voted to head for their old haunt at Cape Lopez, their troop being 'The Royal Fortune'', the' Good Fortune' and 'The Ranger'. Unbeknown to them, Cape Lopez would be their last stopover. While they had been abroad plundering, the British men-o-war 'Swallow' and 'Weymouth 'had been busy too. Though the two ships had their own share of trouble. Sickness on board reduced the crew in numbers and general health.
This had a major impact on their performance, in-fact they could hardly function. At Cape Corso in Ghana they sought new crewmen, forcing them to sea as was the naval tradition in those days but it did not help. The 'Weymouth' was in pitiful condition. News came that Roberts had been sighted and 'The Swallow' was forced to leave the 'Weymouth' behind. Collecting intelligence from passing vessels Captain Ogle realised Roberts would probably try to escape back across the Atlantic and would have to lay up for a while to collect provisions and prepare for the journey.
There were only a few places within reach of Porto-Nova where this was possible and aimed to check them all one by one.